By Nyal Naturals
In Indian households, ghee is not just a food item — it’s an emotion. From temple offerings to Ayurvedic medicines and festive cooking, ghee holds a sacred place. But how we make this golden nectar matters just as much as what it’s made from.
In today’s fast-paced lifestyle, most people prepare ghee on modern gas stoves, but traditionally, our ancestors used the desi chulha — a wood-fired earthen stove. Both methods produce ghee, but the outcome in taste, aroma, nutrition, and energy imprint varies vastly.
In this blog, we compare ghee made on gas stove vs desi chulha, helping you understand which method aligns better with health, heritage, and holistic living.
🥄 What Is Ghee?
Ghee, or clarified butter, is made by simmering butter or cream, removing water and milk solids, and retaining pure fat. In traditional Indian homes, Bilona ghee is made from curd-churned A2 milk, which is then slowly heated to extract ghee.
The final step — heating the butter or makhan — is where the choice of heating source makes all the difference.
🔥 Desi Chulha: The Traditional Firewood Method
The desi chulha, also known as a clay stove, is fueled by dry cow dung cakes, wood, or agricultural waste. It generates slow and consistent heat.
✅ Benefits of Desi Chulha for Ghee Making
-
Slow Cooking Enhances Nutrients
The gradual heat helps retain more nutrients like fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, and K), which can be sensitive to high, direct flames. -
Deep Flavor and Aroma
Ghee made on chulha develops a distinct smoky aroma and nutty flavor that is hard to replicate on gas stoves. -
High-Temperature Stability Without Overheating
The uniform heat of chulha prevents the ghee from burning or overheating — crucial in retaining purity and shelf-life. -
Energy Efficient in Rural Settings
For those with access to wood and dung, chulha is a low-cost, off-grid solution that promotes circular use of farm resources. -
Traditional Wellness Connection
Chulha ghee is deeply rooted in Ayurveda and is often preferred for Panchgavya medicines, havan rituals, and spiritual offerings.
🔥 Gas Stove: The Modern Convenience
The gas stove, fueled by LPG (liquefied petroleum gas), is used in most urban homes. It offers faster cooking and precise flame control.
✅ Advantages of Gas Stove Ghee
-
Time-Saving
Gas flames are intense and consistent, reducing the time needed to make ghee — ideal for busy households. -
Ease of Use
No need to gather wood or cow dung. Just turn a knob and the flame is ready. -
Clean Environment
Gas cooking emits less indoor smoke, which is healthier in enclosed kitchens. -
Consistency in Batches
For small-batch ghee producers in urban setups, LPG stoves provide more control and replication.
❌ Limitations of Each Method
❌ Desi Chulha
- Smoke Pollution: Indoor chulha use without ventilation can cause respiratory problems.
- Time & Labor Intensive: Gathering fuel and monitoring heat demands effort and experience.
- Inconsistent Heat: Without skill, overheating or underheating can spoil the batch.
❌ Gas Stove
- Loss of Traditional Aroma: Lacks the earthy flavor profile associated with chulha ghee.
- Nutrient Degradation: Rapid high heat may destroy some delicate nutrients and antioxidants.
- Energy Source Dependence: Relies on fossil fuels (LPG), which are non-renewable.
⚖️ Comparative Table: Gas Stove vs Desi Chulha for Ghee Making
| Factor | Desi Chulha | Gas Stove |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Type | Slow, radiant heat | Direct, instant flame |
| Aroma & Flavor | Smoky, earthy, nutty | Neutral or light |
| Nutrient Retention | Higher due to slow cooking | Moderate to low |
| Cooking Time | Longer (1–2 hours) | Faster (30–45 minutes) |
| Fuel Source | Cow dung, wood, agri waste | LPG (non-renewable) |
| Energy Cost | Minimal (free for rural users) | Moderate to high |
| Traditional Value | Very high | Low |
| Environmental Impact | Neutral or positive (rural) | CO₂ emission, fossil fuel use |
| Ideal For | Ayurveda, puja, high-quality ghee | Urban use, fast daily ghee needs |
🧬 Science Behind Slow Cooking on Chulha
Slow heat (below 100°C) allows the butterfat to separate gently, minimizing molecular breakdown. This means:
- More intact butyric acid — good for colon health
- Better preservation of CLA (conjugated linoleic acid) — known to boost metabolism
- Retained aromatic aldehydes and ketones — essential for flavor and healing energy
On gas, high heat can destroy or convert these beneficial compounds into less effective forms.
🌿 Ayurveda’s Preference: Chulha Ghee
According to Ayurveda, ghrita (ghee) made with cow's milk and slow-cooked with care retains the sattvic quality — promoting mental clarity, ojas (immunity), and digestive fire (agni).
That's why bilona ghee made on chulha is used in:
- Nasya therapy (for sinus and brain health)
- Deepan and pachan therapies (digestive enhancement)
- Agnihotra and havan rituals
👉 At Nyal Naturals, our A2 Bilona Ghee is made using the slow chulha method to preserve these healing qualities.
🌍 Sustainability and Energy Footprint
With growing awareness of sustainability, the desi chulha method (when smoke is managed well) becomes a carbon-positive choice.
- Cow dung logs are renewable and biodegradable.
- Chulha-based cooking supports village economies and gau shalas.
- Ash from cow dung can be used as bio-fertilizer in farming.
Gas stoves, though cleaner in urban homes, rely on extracted fossil fuels, adding to environmental degradation.
💡 Real-Life Taste Test: Chulha Ghee vs Gas Ghee
We conducted a small tasting session with 10 families. Here’s what they shared:
| Parameter | Chulha Ghee | Gas Stove Ghee |
|---|---|---|
| Smell | Deep, warm, nostalgic | Mild, buttery |
| Texture | Grainy, dense | Smooth, sometimes oily |
| Taste in food | Enhances traditional dishes | Slightly bland in flavor |
| Ayurveda preference | Yes | No |
🏡 The Nyal Naturals Way: Modern Ghee, Traditional Heart
At Nyal Naturals, we believe in blending ancestral wisdom with modern hygiene.
- We use organic A2 milk from Gir cows
- Follow curd-churned Bilona method
- Heat ghee on desi chulha for slow cooking
- Use mud and cow-dung stoves in well-ventilated rural kitchens
- Package in glass jars to retain aroma and purity
By choosing our ghee, you are not just buying a product — you are preserving a tradition.
📘 Read more about Bilona Ghee Process
📣 Final Thoughts
The choice between gas stove ghee and desi chulha ghee goes beyond convenience — it is a matter of taste, tradition, health, and sustainability.
If you seek speed and ease, gas is the modern answer.
But if you value depth of flavor, Ayurvedic energy, and purity, the desi chulha remains unmatched.
In our journey at Nyal Naturals, we walk the path of the ancients — slow, mindful, and full of respect for the cow and the land.
✅ Call to Action
💛 Experience the magic of slow-cooked chulha ghee
🛒 Order Nyal Naturals A2 Bilona Ghee Today
📘 Learn How We Preserve Tradition in Every Drop
🔔 Follow us for more on Instagram | Facebook
Information displayed here are as per information we have from traditional domain or google search engine. You may need to verify information if needed.